Being a trustee and beneficiary of a trust is a complex role that needs to be balanced to keep it fair and legal. A trustee manages and administers the trust assets and must be impartial and in the best interest of all beneficiaries and not self-serving. A beneficiary gets benefits from the trust like distributions or use of assets and has the right to make sure the trust is managed properly.
When one person is both trustee and beneficiary, conflicts of interest can arise. The trustee/beneficiary might be tempted to favor themselves over others, and that can lead to issues in:
Knowing these conflicts is key to navigating the dual roles and for the trustee to be transparent.
A trustee is an individual or entity appointed to manage and administer the assets of a trust. A trustee has a primary responsibility to fulfill their fiduciary duty, which means:
However, when a trustee is also a beneficiary, the overlap of roles and powers gets tricky. This overlap can create conflicts of interest and requires careful navigation to be fair and transparent and fulfill fiduciary duties.
Impartiality is key for trustees, but it becomes hard when the trustee is also a beneficiary. Not managing conflicts of interest can lead to:
Yes, a trustee can absolutely be a beneficiary of the same trust. This arrangement is not only legal but quite common in family trusts. However, there are important considerations potential conflicts, and specific scenarios where this dual role works better than others.
I will teach you everything you need to know about being both a trustee and a beneficiary, including how to avoid problems and get along with others in this tricky situation.
The Short Answer: Yes, With Conditions
Yes, someone can be both the trustee and the beneficiary of the same trust. This arrangement is perfectly legal under U. S. law, but it comes with one critical limitation:
A sole trustee cannot also be the sole beneficiary of a trust.
If one person ends up holding all legal title (as trustee) and all beneficial interest (as beneficiary) with no other beneficiaries involved, the trust arrangement collapses. This is known as the “merger doctrine” – the separation between legal ownership and equitable benefit disappears, and the trust fails.
Understanding the Basic Roles
Before diving deeper, let’s clarify what each role entails
What is a Trustee?
A trustee is the person responsible for managing the trust and its assets. They must:
- Administer the trust according to its terms
- Manage and invest trust assets prudently
- Make distributions to beneficiaries as specified
- Fulfill legal and tax obligations
- Act as a fiduciary (with highest legal duty of care)
What is a Beneficiary?
A beneficiary is simply someone who receives benefits from the trust – whether that’s income, principal distributions, or use of trust property. They’re the people for whom the trust was created.
Common Scenarios Where Trustees Are Also Beneficiaries
This dual arrangement appears in several typical trust situations:
1. Revocable Living Trust
A revocable living trust is the clearest example. In this type of trust, the person who sets it up names themselves as both the trustee and the main beneficiary while they are still alive. There isn’t really a conflict because they have full control and can take back the trust at any time. If they die or can’t do their job, a new trustee takes over and other beneficiaries start getting benefits.
2. Family Trust with Sibling Trustee
Parents often set up a trust and name one child (usually the oldest) as trustee. All of the children are then equal beneficiaries of the trust. When this happens, one sibling runs the trust and gets a share of its money or assets.
3. Spouse as Trustee-Beneficiary
In many marital trusts, a surviving spouse serves as trustee and receives benefits during their lifetime, with children or others named as remainder beneficiaries who inherit after the spouse’s death.
4. Irrevocable Trust with Restricted Powers
Some irrevocable trusts name a beneficiary as trustee but place limits on their power to distribute to themselves – often using the “HEMS standard” (more on that below).
The Pros of Being Both Trustee and Beneficiary
There are genuine advantages to this arrangement:
- Trust and Familiarity: The trustee likely understands the family dynamics and the trust creator’s intentions
- Cost Savings: No need to pay a professional trustee, which can be expensive
- Motivation: The trustee has a personal stake in managing the assets well
- Convenience: Streamlined decision-making without involving outside parties
- Continuity: Family values and goals are maintained through direct family management
The Potential Problems and Conflicts
Despite the benefits, there are serious challenges:
- Inherent Conflict of Interest: The trustee-beneficiary must balance their personal interests against their fiduciary duty to all beneficiaries
- Family Tension: Other beneficiaries might resent or distrust a sibling/relative who has control AND benefits
- Risk of Favoritism: Even unintentionally, the trustee might make decisions that favor their own interests
- Legal Exposure: Mistakes or perceived favoritism can lead to lawsuits from other beneficiaries
- Heavy Responsibility: The dual role carries significant legal and ethical obligations
In one dramatic case, a dispute involving a trustee-beneficiary consumed about 85% of a trust’s assets in legal fees, leaving just 15% for the family to inherit. Such outcomes show how badly things can go wrong without proper safeguards.
Tax Implications: The “HEMS” Standard
One critical aspect many overlook is how this arrangement affects taxes. If a trustee-beneficiary has unlimited power to distribute trust assets to themselves, the IRS might count those assets as part of their taxable estate.
To avoid this tax trap, most trusts include what’s called an “ascertainable standard” for distributions – commonly known as the HEMS standard:
- Health
- Education
- Maintenance
- Support
This limits when and why the trustee-beneficiary can take money from the trust for their personal benefit. By restricting distributions to these specific needs, the trust assets stay outside their taxable estate.
How to Successfully Balance Both Roles
If you find yourself wearing both hats, here are some practical tips:
-
Be transparent with all beneficiaries. Communicate openly and regularly about trust activities.
-
Follow the trust document precisely. It’s your rulebook – if it says you can’t do something, don’t do it.
-
Treat yourself as you would any other beneficiary. Apply the same standards to your own requests as you would to others.
-
Document everything. Keep meticulous records of decisions, distributions, and investments.
-
Get independent advice. Consult with financial advisors, accountants, and trust attorneys to demonstrate impartiality.
-
Consider a co-trustee for major decisions, especially those that affect you personally.
-
Know when to step aside. If conflicts become unmanageable, consider resigning as trustee while maintaining your beneficiary status.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Trustee-beneficiaries often fall into these traps:
❌ “It’s my trust, I can do what I want.” No, you can’t treat it as your personal bank account.
❌ Playing favorites or being greedy. This is the fastest way to court.
❌ Keeping others in the dark. Lack of communication breeds suspicion.
❌ Ignoring the trust terms. The document is your binding guide – follow it.
❌ Poor record-keeping. Without documentation, you can’t prove you acted properly.
❌ Taking the role when you shouldn’t. Sometimes, declining is the wisest choice.
FAQ About Trustees as Beneficiaries
Q: Can a trustee who is a beneficiary pay themselves a fee?
A: Yes, they’re typically entitled to reasonable compensation for their work as trustee, even if they’re also a beneficiary. However, many family trustees waive fees to avoid the appearance of double-dipping.
Q: Can other beneficiaries remove a trustee-beneficiary?
A: Yes. If a trustee (even one who’s also a beneficiary) mismanages the trust or breaches their duties, beneficiaries can petition a court to have them removed.
Q: Is it better to have a professional trustee instead?
A: It depends on your situation. Professional trustees offer expertise and neutrality but charge fees. Family member trustees bring personal knowledge but potential conflicts. For complex or high-conflict situations, a professional might be worth the cost.
Q: What if a trustee-beneficiary makes a mistake?
A: Like any trustee, they can be held personally liable for breaches of fiduciary duty. They might have to repay the trust for losses caused by improper actions.
The Bottom Line
Being both trustee and beneficiary is perfectly legal and can work well with the right approach. The key is balancing your personal interests with your legal obligations to all beneficiaries.
If you’re creating a trust, carefully consider whether naming a beneficiary as trustee makes sense for your family situation. If you’re stepping into this dual role, understand your responsibilities and get professional guidance when needed.
With transparency, fairness, and adherence to the trust terms, you can successfully navigate this potentially complicated but often practical arrangement.
Remember that a trustee’s primary job is to fulfill the trust creator’s intentions – not to maximize their own benefit. When in doubt, put your trustee hat on first and make decisions that serve the trust’s purpose and all its beneficiaries.
What’s the downside of a trust to a beneficiary?
A trust can limit a beneficiary’s access to funds immediately depending on the terms and conditions in the trust document.
Can a beneficiary withdraw money from a trust?
Beneficiaries can withdraw money if allowed by the trust document and applicable laws. Conditions vary depending on the type of trust and the provisions.