Every industry has its shining stars and bad apples. The mortgage industry is no exception. For most consumers, a mortgage will be the single largest purchase they make in their lifetime. This makes picking the right mortgage lender even more important. Its also vital to recognize mortgage scams like loan churning and flipping to avoid becoming a victim. For instance, be prepared to question terms that are too good to be true as well as research real estate agents and lenders so you dont fall for fraudsters.
Choosing a mortgage broker is one of the most important financial decisions you can make when buying a home. While most mortgage brokers are ethical professionals unfortunately some do attempt to scam and defraud their clients. As a homebuyer you need to be aware of common mortgage broker scams and red flags so that you don’t end up as a victim.
What is Mortgage Broker Fraud?
Mortgage broker fraud involves brokers using unethical practices to manipulate mortgage applications, inflate property values, or misrepresent client information for personal financial gain. This can result in clients being approved for mortgages they can’t afford, facing foreclosure, and suffering significant financial losses.
Some common examples of mortgage broker scams include:
-
Income fraud: Inflating the client’s income to qualify for larger loans they can’t repay.
-
Appraisal fraud: Working with appraisers to artificially increase property values to secure bigger mortgages.
-
Identity theft: Using stolen personal information to apply for mortgages without the client’s knowledge.
-
Equity skimming Acquiring distressed properties then stripping their equity through refinancing.
-
Loan flipping: Repeatedly refinancing mortgages to generate fees.
These tactics allow predatory brokers to gain illicit profits while leaving clients with unaffordable debts, damaged credit, and potential foreclosure.
Warning Signs of Mortgage Broker Scams
While mortgage fraud can sometimes be difficult to detect, there are several common red flags to watch out for when working with a broker:
-
Pressure to sign incomplete documents This allows brokers to add terms later without your consent Never sign blank or incomplete paperwork.
-
“Guaranteed approval” promises: Legitimate brokers evaluate your credit history carefully. Guaranteed approvals likely involve inflating your financial credentials.
-
Requests for false information: A broker who advises falsifying income, employment, or assets to qualify for a bigger mortgage demonstrates unethical behavior.
-
Unusually low rates or lenient terms: Offers that seem too good to be true probably are. Make sure terms are in line with current market rates.
-
Vague fee explanations: Fees should be clearly explained in writing. Lack of transparency around fees is a warning sign.
-
Rushing the process: High-pressure tactics prevent you from scrutinizing the loan details thoroughly. Never be rushed into signing.
-
Large upfront fees: While some upfront costs are normal, excessive or hidden fees are suspicious. Make sure all fees are justified and documented.
Staying alert to these red flags helps protect you from potentially fraudulent brokers seeking to take advantage.
6 Ways to Avoid Mortgage Broker Scams
-
Verify licenses and credentials: Check broker licenses and disciplinary records with databases from regulatory bodies like the NMLS, MFAA, or FSRA.
-
Research thoroughly: Search online for broker reviews and complaints. Ask trusted friends and professionals for referrals to reputable brokers.
-
Interview multiple brokers: Compare fees, services, and explanations from several brokers to identify the best fit.
-
Read everything carefully: Scrutinize all documents from initial disclosures to closing papers. Seek legal counsel if unsure. Never sign incomplete forms.
-
Document all interactions: Keep detailed records of communications, paperwork, fees, and advice. This provides evidence if issues arise later.
-
Trust your instincts: Walk away if you feel pressured, misled, or uncomfortable with a broker’s practices. Protect yourself first.
Consequences for Fraudulent Mortgage Brokers
If caught, mortgage brokers engaged in scams face severe legal and financial penalties including:
- Criminal fraud charges, fines, and potential imprisonment
- Loss of professional license and livelihood
- Civil lawsuits, restitution orders, and mandated client compensation
- Permanent reputation damage within the brokerage industry
These repercussions demonstrate why it’s critical for consumers to report any suspected mortgage fraud. This helps prevent ongoing criminal activity and aids in prosecuting predatory brokers so they cannot victimize others.
How to Report Suspected Mortgage Broker Scams
If you believe you may have been the target of a mortgage broker scam, take action quickly:
- Notify your lender or servicer of suspected fraud immediately
- File complaints with authorities such as the FBI, FTC, CFPB, state attorney general
- Contact a HUD counselor for guidance on recovering losses
- Consult an attorney regarding legal remedies and damages
The faster you can report mortgage fraud, the better your chances of recouping financial losses and holding predatory brokers legally accountable. With proper precautions, you can avoid broker scams and work with ethical professionals to achieve homeownership. Stay vigilant and don’t hesitate to speak up if you encounter suspicious mortgage brokerage practices.
In Summary
While most mortgage brokers operate ethically, fraud perpetrated by predatory brokers remains an ongoing threat for homebuyers. Being aware of common broker scams such as inflated income or property values, pressure tactics, and lack of transparency enables you to identify red flags. Conducting thorough research, comparing multiple brokers, scrutinizing paperwork, trusting your instincts, and promptly reporting suspected fraud are key ways you can protect your financial interests and avoid being victimized when purchasing a home. With proper vigilance and caution, you can gain the many benefits of working with a reputable mortgage broker to make your dream of homeownership a reality.
Excessive Loan Costs
Many of the loan costs are fixed no matter how much you borrow. For a larger mortgage, expect the closing costs of your mortgage to be between 2% and 5%. If youre borrowing less than $150,000, costs could exceed 5%. Some lenders will work costs into the loan in the form of a higher interest rate, but the lender should clearly disclose that to you. Always talk to multiple lenders about the total cost of the loan they are proposing. And if the costs are well beyond 5%, ask why before agreeing to the loan.
Prepayment Penalties
For certain loans, lenders can charge a penalty if you pay off your loan early. These prepayment penalties must be disclosed to you in your loan documents. If you see it, ask for a loan with limited or no prepayment penalties.
5 Worst Ways Mortgage Brokers Rip You Off [Lender Scams to Watch Out For]
FAQ
What are the risks of using a mortgage broker?
Disadvantages of Mortgage Brokers
Not every lender works with mortgage brokers, so you may still find a better product and rate by shopping around. Securing a mortgage through a broker may take longer and may require more paperwork, since you don’t have an existing relationship with them like you may have with a bank.
Is it better to use a mortgage broker or not?
A mortgage broker may be a better choice if: You’re self-employed or have an irregular income. If you want access to deals only a broker will be able to get for you. If you want to access more competitive deals or find lenders with less strict criteria.
How do you know if a mortgage scam is a scam?
Mortgage scammers can offer dead giveaways that might suggest they’re not entirely legitimate. Other times, spotting a mortgage scam may be more difficult. As you embark on the mortgage process, here are some of the most common red flags that might suggest a scam is at work. 1. Not Taking Into Account Your Ability to Pay
How can I protect myself from mortgage scams?
To protect yourself from mortgage scams, educate yourself and stay vigilant. Here’s how fraudsters may try to trick you into making a bad decision and some common mortgage scams: Mortgage scams can happen to almost anyone.
How many types of mortgage scams are there?
There are dozens of different mortgage scams. Mortgage scams can be perpetrated by mortgage lenders, real estate agents, investors, and others. In 2021, consumers reported a total of 11,578 internet real estate scams involving mortgage fraud, costing victims over $350 million.
What are the effects of mortgage scams?
The effects of mortgage scams impact every aspect of the home buying process. Since the money lost from mortgage scams can be high value and difficult to recoup, predatory lenders are constantly evolving tactics to evade authorities and trap borrowers.
Is a mortgage scam at work?
As you embark on the mortgage process, here are some of the most common red flags that might suggest a scam is at work. 1. Not Taking Into Account Your Ability to Pay Your mortgage payment should be no more than 28% of your gross monthly income.
What are the different types of mortgage scams?
Scammers take advantage of this by promising homeowners they can offer them more favorable mortgage terms, only to take their money and run. Another type of scam involves borrowers who are preparing to close on a home loan. This type of scam typically involves phishing schemes in which a scammer attempts to steal your banking information.