A person’s will is an important document that shows how they wanted their property to be divided after they died. But what if you’re a beneficiary and think the will should be changed? Can you actually change it? This is a question that many people in this situation have, and the answer isn’t a simple “yes” or “no.”
As someone who’s helped many clients navigate this complex area, I want to give you a clear picture of what’s possible and what isn’t when it comes to beneficiaries changing wills While beneficiaries can’t directly rewrite the will, there are several legal pathways that might help you achieve similar outcomes
Can Beneficiaries Directly Change a Will?
Let’s cut to the chase – no beneficiaries cannot unilaterally change the terms of a will after the testator’s death. A will represents the final wishes of the deceased person (the testator) and once they’ve passed away, the document itself cannot be altered by simply crossing things out or adding new provisions.
However, this doesn’t mean you’re completely without options There are several legitimate ways that beneficiaries can influence how assets are ultimately distributed
Legal Options for Beneficiaries to Modify Inheritance
1. Disclaiming an Inheritance
One of the simplest ways to change your part in a will is to refuse your inheritance altogether. Yes, it might sound strange to some folks, but declining what you’ve been left is absolutely your right.
How disclaiming works:
- You formally decline to accept your inheritance
- The disclaimed assets get redistributed according to the will’s other provisions
- If the will doesn’t specify what happens in this case, the assets pass according to intestacy laws
- This must be done before you accept any benefit from the inheritance
This method is sometimes used to save money on taxes or give assets to the next generation. I’ve seen clients use this method when they were wealthy and wanted their children to get their inheritance right away.
2. Deed of Variation: The Most Common Solution
A deed of variation (sometimes called a deed of family arrangement) is probably the most powerful tool available to beneficiaries who want to change how a will operates.
What is a deed of variation? It is a legal document that lets the beneficiaries agree to change how the assets are distributed according to the will. It basically moves the inheritance from the original recipients to new ones.
To create a valid deed of variation:
- It must be made within 2 years of the death
- All affected beneficiaries must agree to the changes
- It must be in writing and properly witnessed
- It should include clear statements about which elements are changing
- If it affects tax liability, HMRC should receive a copy within 6 months
This approach is commonly used to:
- Add beneficiaries who were born after the will was written (like a grandchild)
- Redirect assets to reduce inheritance tax
- Donate to charity (which can reduce inheritance tax rate to 36%)
- Address perceived unfairness in the original will
Nicola from the Law “.
3. Challenging the Will’s Validity
If you believe the will itself isn’t valid, you might have grounds to contest it entirely. This is a more confrontational approach and should be considered carefully.
Grounds for contesting a will include:
- Lack of testamentary capacity (the person wasn’t mentally able to make a will)
- Undue influence from others
- Improper execution (the will wasn’t signed or witnessed correctly)
- Fraud or forgery
If a will is successfully contested, the court may declare it invalid. In that case, either an earlier valid will applies or, if there isn’t one, intestacy laws determine how assets are distributed.
Important Limitations to Be Aware Of
While these options exist, there are significant limitations to a beneficiary’s ability to influence a will:
- Collective agreement is usually needed – For a deed of variation, all affected beneficiaries must consent to the changes
- Time constraints apply – A deed of variation must be executed within 2 years of death
- You can’t act in bad faith – Beneficiaries cannot use these methods to unfairly increase their own share or exclude others without proper justification
- Some assets pass outside the will – Bank accounts with designated beneficiaries, life insurance policies, and transfer-on-death designations generally override what’s in the will
When Will Modifications Make Sense
From my experience, there are several common scenarios where beneficiaries might legitimately want to modify a will’s outcomes:
Tax Efficiency
One of the most common reasons for changing will distributions is to reduce tax liability. For example:
- Redirecting inheritance to a spouse (who is exempt from inheritance tax)
- Giving a portion to charity (reducing the inheritance tax rate)
- Redistributing assets to make use of multiple tax allowances
Adapting to Changed Circumstances
Sometimes, a will becomes outdated due to changes that occurred between when it was written and when the person died:
- A new family member was born (like a grandchild)
- One beneficiary’s financial situation changed dramatically
- The value or nature of assets changed significantly
Correcting Perceived Unfairness
If beneficiaries collectively feel the will doesn’t reflect what the deceased would have wanted under current circumstances, they might agree to redistribute more fairly.
The Process: How to Change a Will After Death
If you’re considering modifying how a will operates, here’s a practical roadmap:
- Consult with other beneficiaries – Gauge whether there’s general agreement about making changes
- Seek legal advice – The process has technical requirements that must be met
- Draft the deed of variation – This should clearly state what changes are being made
- Get all affected parties to sign – The document must be witnessed properly
- Notify HMRC if relevant – If the changes affect tax liability, HMRC needs to be informed
The process typically takes between 2 weeks to a month, though it can take longer if beneficiaries are minors or lack mental capacity to consent.
Practical Example: How a Deed of Variation Works
Let’s look at a common scenario:
John died leaving his estate equally to his three adult children. One child, Sarah, is very wealthy, while another, Michael, has two children of his own in university with mounting debt. The third sibling, Lisa, feels comfortable financially.
In this situation, the siblings might agree to a deed of variation where:
- Sarah redirects her entire share to Michael’s children
- Lisa keeps her full share
- Michael keeps his share
This arrangement:
- Helps the next generation
- Avoids additional inheritance tax when Sarah would eventually pass assets to her nieces/nephews
- Reflects what the family believes John would have wanted given current circumstances
FAQs About Changing Wills as a Beneficiary
Q: Can you change the executors of a will after death?
A: No, a deed of variation cannot change who the executors are. To remove an executor, they would need to sign a renunciation or you’d need to make a court application.
Q: How long does a deed of variation take?
A: Typically between 2 weeks to a month, though it may take longer in complex situations.
Q: What happens if one beneficiary doesn’t agree to the changes?
A: The deed of variation cannot proceed as planned if any affected beneficiary objects. You may need to negotiate a compromise or pursue other legal options.
Q: Can a bank account beneficiary designation be changed through a will modification?
A: No, bank account beneficiary designations generally override what’s in a will. These are considered non-probate assets that pass directly to the named beneficiary.
Q: Can minor beneficiaries consent to a deed of variation?
A: No, minors cannot legally consent. You may need to make a court application if changes would affect a minor’s inheritance.
Final Thoughts
While beneficiaries can’t directly rewrite a will, the options outlined above provide significant flexibility in how an estate is ultimately distributed. I’ve seen families use these mechanisms to create outcomes that better reflect what they believe their loved one would have wanted, given current circumstances.
If you’re considering any of these options, I strongly recommend seeking proper legal advice. The rules surrounding wills and inheritance can be complex, and mistakes could lead to unintended tax consequences or even invalidate your attempts to modify the distribution.
Remember, the goal should always be to honor the spirit of the deceased’s wishes while adapting to current realities in a way that’s fair to all concerned. When approached thoughtfully and with good intentions, these legal pathways can help families find solutions that work for everyone.
Have you had experience with changing how a will operates after someone’s death? What challenges did you face? I’d love to hear your experiences in the comments below.
