Probate: The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Side of Estate Planning (And Why You Might Want to Avoid It)

No one wants to think about what will happen after they die, let’s be honest. However, if you own things (which we all do), you should likely pay attention to something called “probate.” It’s a word that makes people who plan estates grimace and people who are heirs groan. What is probate, though, and why does it get such a bad name?

What is Probate? The Basics You Need to Know

Probate is basically the court-supervised process of distributing a deceased person’s assets after they die. When someone passes away (with or without a will), their assets typically need to go through this legal process before being handed over to the rightful heirs.

During probate, a court appoints someone (usually called an executor or personal representative) to:

• Gather and inventory all the deceased’s assets
• Pay off any outstanding debts and taxes
• Distribute what’s left to the proper beneficiaries

Sounds simple enough, right? Well, not so fast.

Why Probate Gets a Bad Reputation: The Ugly Truth

There’s a reason why many estate planning experts recommend avoiding probate whenever possible. Actually, there are SEVERAL reasons:

1. Probate Can Take Forever (Almost Literally)

People who don’t like probate often say how long it takes. Genny Bernstein, an estate planning lawyer, says that probate usually takes 9 to 12 months, but it can take a lot longer.

“It’s a series of court orders with certain time measurements you need to meet,” explains Bernstein. In Florida, for example, there’s a mandatory 90-day waiting period just for creditors to file claims against the estate. During this time, you’re just “marshaling assets” and can’t distribute anything.

The process can take up to two years for larger or more complicated estates. Imagine having to wait that long to get an inheritance that you might need right away!

2. Probate is Expensive (Like, Really Expensive)

Probate ain’t cheap, folks. The process involves court costs, attorney fees, executor fees, and other expenses that can quickly add up.

These costs come directly out of the estate assets – which means less money for your loved ones. In some cases, probate expenses can eat up 10% or more of an estate’s value! That’s a big chunk of change that your heirs will never see.

3. Probate Makes Your Private Business Public

An open record is made of a will after it goes through probate. In other words, anyone can walk into the courthouse (or sometimes even look online) and see:

• What assets you owned
• Who your beneficiaries are
• How much money they received

As trusts and estate attorney Asher Rubinstein warns, “When you admit a will into probate, you’re disclosing to the public at large what is in the estate and who the beneficiaries are. That’s risky.”

This lack of privacy can be particularly problematic for wealthy individuals, as it essentially creates “a road map to someone who’s about to come into money.”

4. Probate Creates Opportunities for Scams and Disputes

The public nature of probate creates another problem: it provides an open forum for anyone to challenge the will. This can lead to family disputes, contested wills, and even scam artists targeting new heirs.

Plus, as Rubinstein points out, “If assets are tied up in a probate court, there’s the opportunity cost of having them not invested in the market.” So not only is probate expensive, but it also prevents assets from growing during the lengthy process.

5. Probate Can Be Confusing and Overwhelming

For many families, probate comes at an already difficult time – when they’re grieving the loss of a loved one. Adding complicated legal procedures, paperwork, and court appearances only makes things worse.

Most personal representatives have never served in this role before and find the duties and legal requirements confusing or even overwhelming. This is especially true for someone who already has work and family obligations.

But Wait… Is Probate ALWAYS Bad? The Surprising Pros

Despite all the negatives, probate isn’t inherently evil. In fact, there are some situations where probate might actually be beneficial:

1. Probate Provides Structure and Oversight

The probate process offers a structured framework for settling an estate. This can be particularly helpful in complex family situations or when disputes might arise.

For instance, if there’s concern about whether a personal representative is managing the estate properly, court oversight can provide accountability and a mechanism to remove someone who commits misconduct.

2. Probate Offers Certainty with Creditors

One of the duties of a personal representative is to settle the legitimate debts of an estate. The probate process includes a formal system for notifying creditors and giving them a limited time to make claims.

In most states, creditors have a specific window (often 4 months) to file claims against the estate. If they miss this deadline, the claim is forever barred – meaning heirs won’t have to worry about surprise creditors showing up years later.

3. Probate Can Resolve Disputes

When family members disagree about the validity of a will or how assets should be distributed, probate provides a legal forum to resolve these issues. This can be especially valuable in blended families or situations with estranged relatives.

How to Avoid Probate (If That’s What You Want)

If you’ve decided probate isn’t for you, there are several strategies to keep your assets out of the process:

1. Create a Revocable Living Trust

A living trust is one of the most popular ways to avoid probate. With a trust, you transfer ownership of your assets to the trust during your lifetime, while maintaining control as the trustee.

“You still control those assets while you’re alive,” explains Rubinstein, “and the very same inheritance provisions you put into a will, you put into a trust instead.”

When you pass away, your successor trustee distributes the assets according to your instructions – no probate necessary.

2. Use Payable-on-Death Designations

For financial accounts like bank accounts and investment accounts, you can often designate a beneficiary to receive the funds automatically upon your death. These accounts, sometimes called “payable on death” (POD) accounts, transfer outside of probate.

3. Hold Property in Joint Tenancy

When you own property jointly with someone else “with right of survivorship,” your share automatically passes to the surviving owner when you die – no probate required.

This works well for married couples or partners who own homes together, but be careful about adding others to your deeds just to avoid probate – it can create other problems!

4. Give Assets Away During Your Lifetime

If you’re feeling generous (and don’t need certain assets), you can simply give them away during your lifetime. Just be aware of potential gift tax implications for larger gifts.

So… Should YOU Avoid Probate?

The answer depends on your specific situation. While probate avoidance is often wise, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution.

Consider these factors:

• The size and complexity of your estate
• Your family dynamics (especially if disputes are likely)
• Your privacy concerns
• The laws in your state (some have simplified probate for smaller estates)
• Your budget for estate planning

As Bernstein wisely notes, “You don’t have to leave an estate equally, and you don’t have to leave it to your bloodline. But if you’re not going to do that, you should have a conversation with those people.” Open communication can prevent surprises and reduce the chance of probate disputes.

Final Thoughts: Finding Your Probate Path

Probate isn’t inherently bad – it’s just a process with significant downsides for many situations. The key is understanding what probate means for YOUR specific circumstances and planning accordingly.

Whether you choose to embrace probate’s structure or avoid it entirely, what matters most is creating a clear plan for your assets. Your loved ones will thank you for taking the time to figure this out, even if it means confronting some uncomfortable realities.

And remember – you don’t have to navigate these decisions alone! Consulting with an experienced estate planning attorney can help you understand the best options for your unique situation.

What’s your experience with probate? Have you dealt with the process after a loved one’s passing? I’d love to hear your stories in the comments below!

---

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about probate and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state, and your situation may have unique factors. Please consult with a qualified attorney for specific guidance regarding your estate planning needs.