Many or all of the products on this page are from partners who compensate us when you click to or take an action on their website, but this does not influence our evaluations or ratings. Our opinions are our own.
The investing information provided on this page is for educational purposes only. NerdWallet, Inc. does not offer advisory or brokerage services, nor does it recommend or advise investors to buy or sell particular stocks, securities or other investments.
Robinhood provides free stock, ETF and cryptocurrency trades, a 1% match on IRAs, and its account minimum is $0. Mutual funds and individual bonds arent offered.
The Appealing Façade of Commission-Free Trading
When I first heard about Robinhood, I was skeptical Commission-free trading? No account minimums? An easy-to-use mobile app? It seemed too good to be true And in my experience, when something sounds too good to be true, there’s usually a catch.
Robinhood has disrupted the financial technology industry since its launch in December 2014, attracting over 500,000 people on its waiting list before it even went live. Founded by Stanford physics grads Vladimir Tenev and Baiju Bhatt, the platform aimed to “democratize finance” and bring a new generation of investors into the market.
But is it really as good as it sounds? Let’s dive into what Robinhood actually offers, and more importantly, what catches might be hiding behind that sleek interface
What Robinhood Gets Right
Before we get into the catches, it’s fair to acknowledge what Robinhood does well:
- Commission-free trading on stocks, ETFs, options, and cryptocurrencies
- No account minimums to get started
- User-friendly mobile app available on iOS and Android
- SIPC protection up to $500,000 (including $250,000 for cash)
- Additional security through “excess of SIPC” coverage up to $1.9 million for cash and $50 million for securities per customer
- Regulatory oversight by both the SEC and FINRA
- Retirement options with their Robinhood Retirement IRA (with a 1% match)
These features have made investing accessible to many who previously felt the stock market was out of reach. But accessibility doesn’t always equal optimization.
The Real Catches with Robinhood
1. Payment for Order Flow (PFOF) – The Hidden Revenue Stream
One of the biggest catches with Robinhood is how they make money when they’re not charging commissions. The answer lies in payment for order flow (PFOF).
When you place a trade on Robinhood, instead of routing it directly to an exchange Robinhood sends your order to market makers who execute the trade. These market makers pay Robinhood for this privilege – fractions of a penny per share but it adds up fast with millions of trades.
Why is this a catch? The SEC has actually charged Robinhood with deceiving customers about this practice. When trades are routed based on who pays Robinhood the most rather than what’s best for you, you might not be getting the best execution price on your trades.
2. Service Outages During Critical Trading Times
Remember in 2020 when GameStop and other meme stocks were going crazy? Robinhood experienced major service outages during these high-volume periods, preventing users from buying or selling when they wanted to.
These outages weren’t just inconvenient – they were costly to many investors. So costly, in fact, that Robinhood had to pay a $70 million settlement to FINRA in June 2021 to cover losses experienced due to these outages. That’s the largest penalty FINRA has ever imposed!
3. Limited Investment Tools and Research
If you’re used to platforms like Charles Schwab or E*Trade, you’ll find Robinhood’s investment tools downright primitive. The app offers:
- Basic price charts
- Limited fundamental data
- Minimal screening tools
- No sophisticated technical analysis features
The minimalist approach that makes Robinhood approachable for beginners becomes a serious limitation for anyone looking to make informed investment decisions based on comprehensive research.
4. Poor Portfolio Management Capabilities
Try managing more than three or four positions on Robinhood, and you’ll quickly discover another catch: the platform is terrible for diversified portfolio management.
The app doesn’t provide:
- Easy portfolio allocation views
- Advanced tax lot management
- Integration with other financial tools like Mint or Quicken
- Comprehensive performance reporting
This limitation can lead to poorly diversified portfolios, which is especially dangerous for new investors who might not understand the risks of overweighting certain stocks.
5. The Gamification of Investing
Robinhood’s interface looks more like a game than a serious investment platform. Confetti animations (now removed after criticism), easy-swipe trading, and push notifications all contribute to a gamified experience.
While this makes the app engaging, it also encourages frequent trading – which numerous studies have shown leads to worse investment outcomes for most retail investors. The catch? You might have more fun trading on Robinhood, but you’re likely to make less money in the long run.
6. Cash Management Limitations
Although Robinhood offers a cash sweep program, their rates aren’t always competitive with high-yield savings accounts or money market funds at larger brokerages. For investors with significant uninvested cash, this opportunity cost adds up over time.
7. Customer Service Issues
Need help with your account? Good luck. Robinhood has been criticized for poor customer service, with limited phone support and slow response times. When it’s your money on the line, this lack of support can be frustrating and potentially costly.
Robinhood’s Safety Measures – Are They Enough?
Despite these catches, Robinhood does offer some important safety protections:
| Protection | Coverage |
|---|---|
| SIPC Insurance | Up to $500,000 (including $250,000 for cash) |
| Excess of SIPC | Up to $1.9 million for cash and $50 million for securities |
| Regulatory Oversight | SEC and FINRA regulated |
| Encryption | Sensitive details like Social Security numbers are encrypted |
These protections mean your money is generally safe from brokerage failure or fraud. However, they don’t protect you from market losses or poor investment decisions – which the platform’s limitations might inadvertently encourage.
Who Should (and Shouldn’t) Use Robinhood
Robinhood Might Be Right for You If:
- You’re a beginner investor making your first trades
- You trade infrequently in small amounts
- You’re comfortable doing investment research elsewhere
- You value simplicity over features
- You’re primarily investing in straightforward products like well-known stocks and ETFs
Robinhood Probably Isn’t Right for You If:
- You’re an active trader needing advanced tools
- You have a large portfolio requiring sophisticated management
- You want comprehensive research in one place
- You need responsive customer service
- You trade during volatile market periods
- You want the best possible execution prices
My Personal Experience with Robinhood
When I first downloaded Robinhood, I was impressed by how easy it was to get started. I funded my account, made a few trades, and was hooked on the simplicity. But over time, I noticed that I was making more impulsive trades than I had on other platforms.
The lack of detailed research tools meant I was sometimes buying based on headlines rather than fundamentals. And when I tried to analyze my portfolio’s performance, I found myself exporting data to Excel because the in-app tools were so limited.
The real wake-up call came during a market dip when I couldn’t access the app due to an outage. That’s when I realized the true cost of “free” trades might be higher than I thought.
The Bottom Line: Is Robinhood Worth It?
Robinhood has democratized investing by removing barriers like commissions and minimums. That’s genuinely valuable. But like most things in life, you get what you pay for.
The catches with Robinhood – from PFOF and service outages to limited tools and gamified interfaces – create real costs that might outweigh the benefits of commission-free trading for many investors.
For complete beginners making their first few trades, Robinhood can be a good starting point. But as your investment knowledge and portfolio grow, you’ll likely find yourself bumping up against the platform’s limitations.
My advice? Use Robinhood with your eyes wide open. Understand the catches, the limitations, and the potential costs of “free” trading. And if you decide to use it, consider it one tool in your investment toolkit rather than your only solution.
FAQs About Robinhood’s Catches
Is my money actually safe with Robinhood?
Yes, from a regulatory standpoint. Robinhood is covered by SIPC insurance up to $500,000 and offers excess coverage beyond that. They’re also regulated by the SEC and FINRA. However, this doesn’t protect you from market losses or service outages that prevent timely trades.
How does Robinhood make money if trades are free?
Primarily through payment for order flow (PFOF), where market makers pay Robinhood to execute your trades. They also earn money from Robinhood Gold subscriptions ($50 annually), margin lending, and interest on uninvested cash.
Is Robinhood good for beginners?
It’s user-friendly for beginners, but the lack of educational tools and research, combined with the gamified interface, might encourage poor investing habits. Beginners might be better served by platforms that offer more guidance and less gamification.
What happened with Robinhood during the GameStop saga?
During the January 2021 meme stock frenzy, Robinhood restricted trading on certain volatile stocks including GameStop. They claimed this was due to clearinghouse requirements, but many users felt betrayed and filed lawsuits. This incident highlighted the potential limitations of the platform during extreme market conditions.
Can I transfer my investments from Robinhood to another broker?
Yes, but Robinhood charges a $75 fee for account transfers – another “catch” to be aware of. Most other brokerages charge similar fees, though some will reimburse this cost when you transfer to them.
Remember, when it comes to investing, understanding the true costs extends far beyond just looking at commission fees. The real catches with Robinhood might not be immediately obvious, but they could impact your investment success in the long run.
Other key Robinhood features
Robinhoods customer support features include 24/7 in-app chat, and extended-hours phone support available from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m Eastern time, Monday – Friday.
Robinhood also has an easily-navigable website, and a library of hundreds of educational articles as well as the “Investors Guild” blog of expert commentary, plus a YouTube show.
As mentioned above, Robinhood IRAs come with several features that are unusual for non-employer-sponsored retirement accounts, including a 1% match on contributions and a 3% match for Gold members (subject to a take-back provision if funds are withdrawn in less than five years), instant deposits up to $1,000, and recommended portfolios of ETFs. (Heres more on how Robinhood IRAs work.)
Robinhood shook up the IRA market with its 1% match on contributions — an offer that is typically only available through employer retirement plans. While some competitors have since added similar offers, it is still relatively rare among IRA providers.
Compared with Robinhoods free account tier, Robinhood Gold pays investors higher rates on uninvested cash, matches a higher percentage of IRA contributions, and provides access to research from Morningstar and market data from Nasdaq. The opt-in service carries a flat monthly fee of $5.
As of this review, Robinhood Gold members get over 4% interest on their uninvested brokerage cash — one of the highest interest rates among similar brokers — and that money is swept into an affiliated bank account.
Gold members are also eligible for the Robinhood Gold Card, a credit card that offers 3% cash back on all purchases, and 5% cash back on travel purchases booked through the Robinhood travel portal. The card has no additional annual fees and no foreign transaction fees, and comes with perks like concierge service.
Its worth asking yourself if you really need those features when deciding whether or not Robinhood Gold is worth it for you.
Robinhood also offers a spending account that comes with a debit card and $250,000 in Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation insurance via agreements with partner banks. The spending account allows users to send or receive money, set up direct deposit, and set up recurring investments from their paycheck.
Robinhood spending accounts also come with some unusual features, such as an opt-in program that lets users get their direct deposit paychecks up to two days early. Users can also opt to have their debit card transactions rounded up to the next dollar, with the extra change invested in stocks or funds. This round-up feature is similar to the round-up investing tactics made famous by robo-advisors Acorns and Stash.
How we nerd out testing trading platforms
Our reviewers — who are writers and editors on NerdWallet’s content team — hands-on test every online broker platform in our analysis. That way, we’re able to report on every aspect of the user experience, from funding a new account to actually placing trades.
We score each broker against a set of criteria that factors in both the capabilities offered and the actual user experience of trading with those capabilities. This includes how easy it was to sign up for and fund a new account. Note that a broker may score very highly for the platforms it offers, but low for the experience of actually using that platform. These are scored separately in our analysis, and they are weighted evenly when factored into the broker’s overall score. This means a broker can offer an advanced trading platform, but if it is clunky to use or the process of opening an account is unnecessarily arduous, that will be reflected in their score.
However, Robinhood loses marks in the trading platform category due to accepting payment for order flow (PFOF). In the last few years, regulators have expressed concern that the PFOF business model is a conflict of interest; it involves market-making firms paying brokers to route customer orders through them. Although its effects are negligible for most investors, its possible PFOF brokers could execute orders slightly slower or at slightly worse prices than non-PFOF brokers. Robinhood reported its order execution quality is 95.62%, slightly worse than the average among brokers we review.
The average execution quality of all brokers we review was 97.51% as of Oct. 15, 2025. That means 97.51% of orders sold for at a price that was at or better than the National Best Bid and Offer. Executing at or above the NBBO means you may receive a price improvement or a better share price than you were originally quoted.
The securities available to trade at Robinhood are limited. Mutual funds and bonds aren’t supported, which can help build a diversified, long-term portfolio. Robinhood does, however, offer access to more than 650 foreign companies via American Depository Receipts. It also offers exchange-traded funds, including index and bond ETFs, and its working on launching futures trading in the months ahead. In late 2024, Robinhood also briefly offered a prediction market that allowed investors to bet on the 2024 election.
Like some other brokers, including Interactive Brokers, Fidelity and Charles Schwab, Robinhood offers fractional shares. That means you can pay as little as $1 for a portion of a share, even if that stocks full share price is in the hundreds of dollars. This feature makes it much easier to build a diversified portfolio — youre able to buy stock in many more companies, even if you dont have a lot of money to invest.
Robinhoods taxable brokerage accounts allow margin trading, and offer some of the lowest margin rates in the business. Margin trading is not available in IRAs.
Crypto offering: Unlike many traditional brokerages, Robinhood users can buy 15 cryptocurrencies right in their taxable brokerage account. Whats more, its almost entirely free — the only non-network fee that Robinhood charges is 0.5% to 1.5% for purchasing crypto with a debit card.
Robinhood’s cryptocurrency trading is available in every U.S. state, although Stellar (XLM), Tezos (XTZ), Uniswap (UNI) and USD Coin (USDC) are not available in New York, and USDC is not available in Texas. You can begin trading with as little as $1. Crypto-crypto trading pairs are not available, nor is crypto staking.
The list of available cryptocurrencies is much smaller than youll find at a true crypto brokerage, but its among the largest selections of any stock trading app we review. Robinhood only offers crypto trading in taxable brokerage accounts — not in IRAs. Customers can withdraw crypto from Robinhood to a wallet of their choice.