What Is an Options Collar? The Ultimate Protection Strategy for Your Investments

Have you ever found yourself sitting on some juicy stock gains but worried the market might suddenly tank? Or maybe you’re holding onto a stock you love long-term, but you’re sweating about short-term volatility? If that’s you, then an options collar strategy might be your new best friend.

In this article, I’ll break down exactly what an options collar is, how it works, and when you might want to use one. No fancy financial jargon – just plain talk about a powerful strategy that could help protect your investment portfolio.

The Options Collar Strategy Explained Simply

An options collar is like putting a safety helmet on your stock investments. It’s a hedging strategy that protects you from big losses while still letting you participate in some upside gains.

Here’s the simple version When you set up an options collar. you’re doing two things at the same time

1. Buying a protective put option (which acts like insurance against your stock dropping too much)
2. Selling a covered call option (which generates income but limits how much you can profit if the stock soars)

Both of these options are typically “out-of-the-money” (OTM), meaning the strike prices are set above (for the call) or below (for the put) the current stock price.

Think of it like putting both a floor and a ceiling on your stock position – hence the name “collar,” The stock gets “collared” between these two price points

The Building Blocks of an Options Collar

Let’s break down the two main components:

Component #1: The Protective Put

This is your safety net. When you buy a protective put, you’re purchasing the right to sell your stock at a specific price (the strike price), even if the market value drops lower.

For example, if you own a stock trading at $90 and buy an $85 put, you’re guaranteeing you can sell your shares for at least $85 each, even if the market price crashes to $60.

The catch? This insurance isn’t free – you pay a premium for that put option.

Component #2: The Covered Call

This is how you offset the cost of your insurance. When you sell a covered call, you’re giving someone else the right to buy your stock at a specified price.

For instance, if your stock is at $90 and you sell a $95 call, you collect a premium upfront. However, if the stock rises above $95, you’ll have to sell at that price, limiting your upside.

How an Options Collar Works in Practice

Let me walk you through a real-world example:

Imagine you own 100 shares of XYZ stock that you bought at $80 per share. The stock has done well and is now trading at $90.

You’re happy with the gains but worried about a potential market downturn. Here’s how you might set up a collar:

1. Buy a protective put with a strike price of $85 for a premium of $3 per share ($300 total)
2. Sell a covered call with a strike price of $95 for a premium of $4 per share ($400 total)

Let’s analyze what you’ve done:

• You’ve created a floor at $85, meaning the worst your position can do is drop to $85 (minus the net cost of the options)
• You’ve capped your upside at $95, meaning even if the stock shoots to $120, you’ll have to sell at $95
• The call premium ($400) more than covers your put cost ($300), giving you a net credit of $100

Break-Even Points and Potential Outcomes

When using an options collar, there are three possible scenarios:

Scenario 1: Stock Stays Between the Strike Prices

If XYZ stays between $85 and $95 until expiration, both options expire worthless. You keep the net credit and continue owning the stock.

Scenario 2: Stock Drops Below Put Strike

If XYZ drops below $85, your put protects you. Your maximum loss is:

• Put strike ($85) – Original purchase price ($80) – Net premium collected ($1) = $4 per share

Scenario 3: Stock Rises Above Call Strike

If XYZ rises above $95, your call will likely be exercised. Your maximum profit is:

• Call strike ($95) – Original purchase price ($80) + Net premium collected ($1) = $16 per share

When Should You Use an Options Collar?

An options collar strategy isn’t for everyone or every situation. Here’s when it makes the most sense:

• When you’re sitting on unrealized gains that you want to protect
• During periods of high market uncertainty or expected volatility
• When you’re moderately bullish or neutral on a stock
• When you’re approaching a financial goal and capital preservation becomes more important than potential gains
• When options premiums are high due to increased volatility, making it easier to create a zero-cost collar

Pros and Cons of Using Options Collars

Like any strategy, options collars have their advantages and drawbacks.

The Good Stuff

• Downside protection against significant losses
• Potential for zero cost or even a net credit when setting up
• Peace of mind during volatile market periods
• Simple to understand compared to more complex options strategies

The Not-So-Good Stuff

• Limited upside potential if your stock takes off
• Additional transaction costs from multiple options trades
• Tax complications (especially in taxable accounts)
• Risk of early assignment on the short call

Common Tax Considerations

The tax implications of collars can get tricky. Here are some things to watch out for:

• Income from a collar is typically taxed at your ordinary income rate
• Setting up a collar could potentially reset the holding period of your stock
• If your stock pays a dividend while collared, it might not qualify for the favorable 15% long-term rate
• Wash sale rules may apply if you close the position at a loss and repurchase within 30 days

I strongly recommend talking to a tax professional before implementing this strategy in taxable accounts.

Zero-Cost Collars: The Holy Grail?

A “zero-cost collar” occurs when the premium received from selling the call exactly offsets the cost of buying the put. Some traders even aim for a “credit collar,” where you actually receive more premium than you pay out.

While this sounds ideal, remember that nothing is truly free in investing. The tighter you make your collar (smaller distance between put and call strikes), the more you limit your potential upside.

Dynamic Collars: A Strategy for the Pros

Some institutional investors use a more advanced approach called a “dynamic collar.” This involves actively adjusting the collar as the stock price moves.

For instance, if your stock is trending upward, you might roll your options to higher strikes and further expiration dates. This strategy requires more active management and monitoring but can be effective for building larger positions over time.

How to Set Up an Options Collar in 5 Steps

If you’re interested in trying this strategy, here’s a simple roadmap:

1. Own the underlying stock (typically 100 shares per options contract)
2. Decide on your downside protection level and buy a put at that strike price
3. Determine how much upside you’re willing to give up and sell a call at that strike price
4. Choose an expiration date (typically the same for both options)
5. Monitor the position and be prepared to adjust as needed

Real-World Example: Building a Collar on AAPL

Let’s say you own 100 shares of Apple (AAPL) that you bought at $150, and it’s now trading at $180. You want to protect your $30 per share gain but still participate if AAPL continues to rise moderately.

You might:

• Buy a put with a strike price of $170 for $5 per share
• Sell a call with a strike price of $190 for $5 per share

This creates a zero-cost collar where:

• Your downside is protected at $170 (you can only lose $10 per share from the current price)
• Your upside is capped at $190 (you can only gain another $10 per share)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

When implementing an options collar, watch out for these pitfalls:

• Choosing options that are too close to expiration (not giving your strategy enough time to work)
• Setting strike prices too close together (overly restricting your potential returns)
• Ignoring liquidity in the options you select (leading to poor execution prices)
• Forgetting about dividend dates (which can increase the risk of early assignment)
• Not accounting for transaction costs when calculating potential profits

Final Thoughts: Is an Options Collar Right for You?

An options collar is a powerful risk management tool that can help you sleep better during market turbulence. It’s perfect for investors who want to protect accumulated gains while maintaining some upside potential.

However, it’s not the best choice if you’re extremely bullish on a stock or if you’re looking to maximize returns in a strongly trending market.

Remember, successful investing isn’t just about maximizing gains – it’s also about managing risk. And sometimes, putting a collar around your most valuable positions is the smartest move you can make.

Have you ever used an options collar strategy? What was your experience like? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below!

---

A 5% collar is an options trading strategy that limits potential losses and gains to approximately a 5% range by buying a protective put and selling a covered call with strike prices around 5% below and above the underlying asset’s current price. This strategy is used to hedge a long stock position against a downturn while also capping upside potential.