The Day Trading Nightmare Nobody Warns You About
Look, I’ve been there – one minute you’re making a few quick trades, feeling like a Wall Street hotshot, and the next thing you know BAM! You’re slapped with a Pattern Day Trader flag that turns your trading account into a financial prison
If you’ve recently discovered you’re flagged as a pattern day trader (PDT) or worried it might happen to you, don’t panic! I’m gonna walk you through everything about what happens, why it happens, and what your options are.
What Exactly is Pattern Day Trading?
Before we dive into the consequences, let’s get crystal clear on what pattern day trading actually is.
A day trade happens when you
- Buy and sell the same stock or ETF within a single trading day
- Open and close the same options contracts within a single trading day
The trading day ends at 8 PM ET. Any trades during overnight hours (8 PM-12 AM ET) count for the next trading day.
You become flagged as a pattern day trader when:
- You make 4+ day trades within 5 trading days
- These day trades represent more than 6% of your total trades in that same period
The Moment You Get Flagged – What Actually Happens?
So you’ve placed that 4th day trade within a 5-day period… now what? Here’s the immediate impact:
-
Account Restriction: Your account gets flagged for pattern day trading.
-
The $25K Requirement: To continue day trading, you now need to maintain a portfolio value of at least $25,000. This doesn’t include crypto positions, futures positions, or available margin.
-
Daily Check: Your portfolio value may fluctuate during the day, but Robinhood only considers the closing balance of the previous trading day to determine if you meet the requirement.
-
Position Closing Only: If your account falls below $25K while flagged, you might be restricted to “position closing only” – meaning you can only close positions but can’t open new ones.
-
Program Pauses: If you’re in a margin account, your participation in Robinhood’s Sweep and Stock Lending programs gets paused. No more earning interest!
One thing that surprised me is that the PDT flag is indefinite – it won’t just disappear after the 5-day period ends. This is a FINRA regulation that all brokerages must follow.
Your Options After Getting Flagged
Don’t worry, all is not lost! You have several options if you find yourself flagged:
Option 1: Maintain $25K+ in Your Account
If you’ve got the funds, the simplest solution is to maintain at least $25,000 in your portfolio. This won’t remove the PDT flag, but it lets you continue day trading without restrictions.
Option 2: Use Your One-Time Flag Removal
Robinhood offers a one-time courtesy PDT flag removal. This is basically your “get out of jail free” card, but use it wisely because it’s truly a one-time thing!
To use your one-time removal:
- Go to Robinhood’s help center
- Check if you’re eligible for the removal
- Follow the process to have the flag removed
Option 3: Switch to a Cash Account
This is my personal favorite solution if you don’t have $25K. PDT restrictions only apply to margin accounts! By switching to a cash account:
- You can trade without worrying about day trade limits
- You regain access to the Stock Lending program
- You can participate in the Brokerage Cash Sweep program again
The downside? You can’t trade on unsettled funds from stock, ETF, and options sales while in a cash account.
Option 4: Wait It Out and Trade Carefully
If none of the above options work for you, you can:
- Continue to hold your existing investments
- Make fewer than 4 day trades in any rolling 5 trading day period
- Place trades that don’t count as day trades
How to Check Your Day Trade Count
It’s crucial to keep track of your day trades to avoid getting flagged. In the Robinhood app:
- Select Account → Menu (3 bars) or Settings
- Select Investing → Day trades
This will show how many day trades you’ve made in the current 5 trading day window.
Smart Move: Turn On Pattern Day Trade Protection
One feature I wish I’d known about earlier is Pattern Day Trade Protection. This is a lifesaver that alerts you when you’re about to place your 4th day trade, giving you the option to proceed or cancel. To enable it:
- Go to Account → Menu (3 bars) or Settings
- Select Investing → Day trade settings
- Make sure Pattern Day Trade Protection is turned On
Sneaky Day Trading Situations to Watch Out For
There are some tricky situations that can cause unexpected day trades:
Multiple Executions
Large orders or orders on low-volume stocks might get split into multiple executions. For example, an order to buy 10,000 shares might execute in chunks:
- Buy 1,000 shares
- Buy 2,000 shares
- Buy 3,000 shares
- Buy 1,500 shares
- Buy 2,500 shares
If you place a sell order before your buy order is completely filled, you risk executing multiple day trades!
Options and Complex Trades
Options day trades work similarly. If you:
- Buy-to-open and then sell-to-close the same option contract within a day = 1 day trade
- Sell-to-open and then buy-to-close the same option contract within a day = 1 day trade
Even exercising options can count as day trades if you open and close the resulting stock position on the same day.
Real Life Examples to Clarify Day Trading
Example 1: Simple Day Trade
Starting with zero shares of ABC:
- Buy 1 ABC
- Sell 1 ABC
= 1 day trade
Example 2: Already Owning Shares
Starting with 10 shares of ABC:
- Sell 10 ABC
- Buy 5 ABC
- Sell 5 ABC
= 1 day trade
Example 3: Multiple Buys and Sells
Starting with zero ABC:
- Buy 1 ABC
- Buy 2 ABC
- Buy 7 ABC
- Sell 1 ABC
- Sell 5 ABC
- Sell 4 ABC
= 1 day trade (only 1 change in direction from buys to sells)
Example 4: Two Day Trades
Starting with zero ABC:
- Buy 50 ABC
- Sell 15 ABC
- Sell 35 ABC
- Buy 10 ABC
- Sell 10 ABC
= 2 day trades (2 changes in direction from buys to sells)
PDT Impact on Multiple Accounts
This is important! PDT rules apply at the USER level, not the account level. If your margin account is flagged for PDT and you switch it to cash, then switch another account to margin, the PDT flag carries over to the new margin account.
Your one-time removal also applies at the user level across all your accounts.
My Personal Advice Based on Experience
After dealing with PDT restrictions myself, here’s what I’ve learned:
-
Plan Your Trades: Think ahead about what trades you’ll make in a 5-day period.
-
Use Cash Accounts for Small Accounts: If you have less than $25K, seriously consider a cash account.
-
Save Your One-Time Removal: Don’t use your one-time removal unless absolutely necessary.
-
Be Careful with Market Orders: Limit orders give you more control and help avoid unexpected executions.
-
Check Your Day Trade Count Daily: Make it part of your trading routine to check your day trade count.
Special Considerations for Robinhood Users
If you’re using Robinhood specifically (which the article is from), be aware of these platform-specific details:
-
Extended-Hours Trading: Trades during extended hours follow the same PDT rules. A trade at 8:01 PM ET on Monday and a sell at 10 AM ET on Tuesday count as 1 day trade.
-
Brokerage Cash Sweep: While flagged as PDT in a margin account, you won’t earn interest on swept cash.
-
Stock Lending Program: You’re ineligible to participate in Stock Lending while flagged as PDT in a margin account, regardless of your portfolio value.
Bottom Line
Getting flagged as a pattern day trader isn’t the end of your trading journey, but it does change the rules you have to play by. Your best options are:
- Maintain $25,000+ in your account
- Switch to a cash account
- Use your one-time PDT flag removal
- Trade more carefully and monitor your day trades
Remember that the PDT rule isn’t just a Robinhood thing – it’s a FINRA regulation that all brokers must enforce.
FAQs About Pattern Day Trading Flags
Q: How long does a PDT flag last?
A: Per FINRA regulation, PDT flags remain on your account indefinitely, outside of extraordinary circumstances.
Q: Can I day trade cryptocurrencies without worrying about PDT rules?
A: Yes! PDT rules only apply to stocks, ETFs, and options – not to cryptocurrencies.
Q: Do I need exactly $25,000 to day trade?
A: You need to maintain a portfolio value of at least $25,000 at the end of each trading day to continue day trading while flagged as a PDT.
Q: What happens if I get flagged on multiple platforms?
A: PDT flags are specific to each brokerage, so getting flagged on Robinhood doesn’t affect your accounts at other brokers.
Q: Can I still invest while PDT flagged?
A: Yes! You can still make investments – you just can’t day trade unless you meet the $25K requirement.
Do pattern day trader rules apply to cash accounts?
Pattern day-trading rules apply only to margin accounts. So, no. They don’t apply to cash accounts. But day-trading in a cash account can come with potentially worse repercussions.
If you attempt to day-trade in a cash account, you run the risk of “free riding.” This means you might buy and then sell a security before the transaction settles. In May 2024, U.S. securities markets reduced the settlement period for securities from T+2 to T+1. In a cash account, your capital and any proceeds from the sale of a security ought to be tied up for the same period.
If somehow you’re able to continue trading before your previous trade settles, then you’re using unsettled proceeds—not settled cash—to trade. In other words, you’re getting a free ride and not committing your settled funds. This is a violation of the Federal Reserve Board’s Regulation T.
And if you’re a repeat offender? Your trading account can actually get suspended. Ouch.
What is a pattern day trader?
If you trade actively in a margin account, then it might just be a matter of time before you stumble across the pattern day trader (PDT) rules. But if you’re like many semi-active investors, triggering the PDT alarm could be accidental. Maybe:
- You got into a trade at a bad (or suboptimal) entry price, so you liquidated it immediately, but then decided later in the day to try again.
- You changed your mind about a stock purchase and dumped it right away.
- You typed in the wrong ticker symbol, causing you to buy the wrong stock. So you sold it immediately.
If you repeat any of these actions four times within five business days, you’ll raise the pattern day trader flag. You’ll probably get a call from your broker (or you’ll receive some other form of notification). They’ll ask you to bring your account balance up to $25,000 or to cease day-trading for a specified period, such as 90 calendar days.
So what just happened, and what can you expect moving forward?
- A pattern day trader (PDT) is someone who makes four or more day-trades within five business days using a margin account.
- Once flagged as a PDT, a trader may be required to maintain a minimum account balance of $25,000.
- There are tradable assets not subject to PDT rules, but they have their own rules and capital requirements.